Tuesday, September 21, 2010

More on class prep

One of the "career advice" articles in IHE contains an outline of what is termed the Sunday Meeting.

This is first rate, although I don't find it all that revolutionary. I've always done that.

Indeed, I've done some of it over the summer so my entire semester is planned out on a calendar that combines all of the major tasks for every class I teach or have important managerial responsibilities to carry out.

Now it is time to get back to my regularly scheduled Tuesday Grading.


Read Entire Article......

Sunday, September 19, 2010

Preparing for class

There is a nice question/poll today from Unbalanced Reaction concerning prep time for class. I'm in the 1 to 15 minute category, but that is for classes that I have taught (many times) before and represents an average that often includes zero if "prep" means actually writing out detailed notes for what will happen in class.

And that isn't because I use my old notes in class, even though I have them with me.

I sensed this incipient digression as I wrote my comment at UR's place, so I will digress here instead. Most of my prep time is spent on the broad outline of what I will do, what might be considered a lesson plan if actually contained any detail beyond Problem x or Example of topic y.

Prep is usually more about clearing my mind to see if there is something new I should try. Lately that means what I write below, but also an approach that puts EVERY key formula for a new subject up on the screen, rather than having them show up here and there as we deal with new parts of a single topic. Then I only use those few things in everything else I do.

I used to have problems worked out so I could "work" them without having to pause to do calculations, but I have decided that is a bad model for the students even if I pause to use an air calculator before writing the answer down. It turns out that, despite being a digital non-native (wrote my first computer program my senior year in HS and didn't own a calculator until I started grad school), I am a lot faster than most of them are at slamming the keys.

So I might project a problem, either prepared or out of the book, but then all of it gets done for real in class. I've observed people who have the answers on plastic or ppt, and the kids (who I am also observing) just don't get the details. Sometimes they can't see the details, other times they just follow the terse bits on a ppt printout outline -- but never put together a coherent solution. Of course, some don't ever take good notes or recognize my board work as how I actually do the problem myself, but that is a different problem that requires constant teaching effort.

The only time I make sure I have the worked version handy is when I put up a problem for them to do. Then I want to be able to flash memorize the key results so I can provide right/wrong advice as I move around the room.

The important thing is that I have fixed in my head the need to be very procedural in everything I do in class. I don't need notes for that. In fact, my notes are not as good as what I put on the board.


Read Entire Article......

Three Un-related Topics

All below the jump ... thoughts about perceived quality of faculty at a CC, the Gates Foundation and education, and keeping happy as a professor -- all triggered by recent items in IHE.


Faculty quality at the CC Level

Hat tip to an IHE Quick Take, pointing to this article in the Detroit News. Michigan is apparently facing the question of whether community colleges should be allowed to offer 4-year degrees in selected fields. They probably got the idea from other states where CCs now offer BS degrees in nursing or education.

Michael Boulus, executive director of the Presidents Council of State Universities of Michigan, said:

"Community colleges do not have the base of professional educators needed to provide accredited bachelor's degrees."

to which I say "BS". Reminds me of nearby Wannabe Flagship, where they try to claim that our organic chem class (30 students) is worse than theirs (300 students) when our professor used to teach ... THEIR class as an adjunct!

I'll use nursing as an example, since it is an area where there remains some prejudice against licensed RNs who earned an AS rather than a BS degree. (Yes, I know that you cannot move up into surgery or anesthesiology without the BSN degree, but I am talking about entry level positions.) It is convenient because I can look at the requirements for the degree at Wannabe Flagship and see clearly that (a) they do require important non-nursing courses that are not in our AS program, and (b) our CC teaches every one of those non-nursing courses at a level that they accept for transfer students, and (c) that many of their classes are taught by adjuncts and typical adjuncts and full-time faculty have an MSN as their top degree. There are some doctorates (including an EdD or two), but those are only needed for the MS and Doctoral programs, not the undergrad BSN degree program, which explains why there are so few of them.

Our faculty are just as educated, experienced, and licensed as theirs are and could teach the same upper-division classes that theirs teach. Our program is accredited for the RN license by the same national organization that theirs is, and ours has the same high pass rate that theirs does ... and higher than some other programs in the state. Yes, we do need to hire more faculty, but that is just for our growing AS degree program. You see, Wannabe Flagship has very limited admissions and does not offer any program that can be taken by non-traditional students, so we turn away many qualified students. And there is no shortage of demand, even in today's economy.

The propagandist for the state universities in Michigan is either a liar or ignorant.


Education Research

A Friday Viewpoint at IHE posed a challenge to the Gates Foundation to fund more research, but I have in mind some nonsense embedded in the article.

The author says:
There were some 65,000 doctorates in education granted over the last 10 years for which we have data (1999-2008). During the same period, there were about 21,000 doctorates awarded in chemistry. Which do you think has had the greatest consequences, knowledge-wise?

I know that comparing education and chemistry in this way is unreasonable; for one thing, many of the education degrees were awarded to practitioners, rather than to researchers.

BZZZZT, but thank you for playing. Those persons with a chemistry PhD are all, every last one of them, practitioners. And that identifies the main problem with education degree programs. Few of them have faculty whose research is based on actually doing (say, teaching elementary school) what they teach. In contrast, that chemistry PhD actually does chemistry, including the ones who are teaching chemistry at a university. In my opinion, that is why education research has not made as much of a dent in our national K-12 problem as, say, chemistry research has improved batteries and many other important products.

I might add more (like references to what others said about Gates and accountability for outcomes from those projects), but time to move on.


Enjoying the job

Also from Friday, we have this ad dressed up as Career Advice from IHE. There are some good things in there worth thinking about, but I'll start by observing that if you get migraines as a stress reaction to the research demands of your 1-1 teaching job at an R1, you really should think about moving to a teaching intensive college or do what the author did: Join a leadership program to learn how to manage research (rather than do research) and start the move up into Provost world.

The real lesson in there, which does not require buying the book, is that you need to identify your "soulful values" and set your goals around them. Since regular goal setting is part of what every professor at my college does each year (as a way to encourage us to stay "fresh"), that is a useful way to think about how to choose among many things that one can do to improve teaching.


Read Entire Article......

Sunday, September 5, 2010

English?

Ah, two nations separated by a common language.

I see every indication that the following part of a story is written in English, but I have only the vaguest idea[*] what they are talking about. See for yourself:

Spinner Graeme Swann found massive turn to take 2-14 as Pakistan struggled.

England also had batting problems, but Eoin Morgan and Michael Yardy put on 67 from 43 balls in a five-wicket win.

They came together after Luke Wright had been bowled on the sweep for a duck, leaving England in a precarious position at 62-5 after 10 overs in Cardiff.

Many players on both sides had made batting look difficult on a slow wicket, with the ball stopping in the pitch.

I wonder if the British feel the same way when they read the description of someone "throwing a pitch" in baseball!

But one thing I like about British sportswriters is that they don't mind being rude when describing someone who "produced a series of desperate swishes at fresh air". We could use a bit of that when a millionaire strikes out.

[*]
I know a bit more than I let on. I've actually played a bizarre version of street cricket (using trash cans for wickets) with some Aussie-Americans, but it would take a lot of gin for me to sit and watch a match on TV. But I am only guessing at what "2-14" means, and I have no clue at all what a "duck" might be.


Read Entire Article......

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

Mentoring

Today I am blogging to myself. You see, I know I wrote several brilliant ?? comments giving advice to new faculty and my thoughts on mentoring new faculty, and ... well ... now I am a mentor to a new faculty member. So what was it I said?

Took more time to find these than I thought it would.

Mentoring New Faculty (April 2008)
Concerning my thoughts about our college's mentoring program.

Advice for a New Professor (March 2009)
Includes links to two other articles and a few thoughts of my own.

New Adjunct (July 2007)
Although directed at a question from a first-time teacher, some of this is probably relevant in many situations.

I'm sure there are others (like in my "jobs" area or dialogs on other blogs), but I don't have time to track those down right now. Will update later when I think of one.

Dean Dad on becoming an Administrator
On one level, completely irrelevant. On another, totally relevant. Anyone in a new job has to learn, and listening is how you learn. For that matter, even people who have been on the job for years still have things to learn. Listening is how learning happens.


Read Entire Article......

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

It's a miracle!

The VERY long-awaited assessment of research doctoral programs by the National Research Council is, so they say, going to be released on September 28.

I think that makes this update of the 1982 and 1995 reports about two years late.

Why? Could the fact that they will release a revised version of the Methodology guide, updating the 2009 update of the 2003 report that proposed a methodology for this new set of rankings have anything to do with it?

It sure sounds like they kept tweaking the methodology until they got what they wanted. Will there be a hue and cry? We will see. The biggest problem is that the data it uses are so old that they will probably have to start the next study before ink is dry on this one.

However ...

I can't wait to see if that means "traditional" top schools remain above one physics program that I thought should have been marked with a bullet (record rating lingo) based on some of the raw data from 1995. Those data suggested that one program in particular had higher cites and other objective measures of research quality than the schools between it and #1.

For the record, that program was #10 UC Santa Barbara. Their Pubs per faculty number was second only to #1 Harvard, and their cites per faculty (178) exceeded Harvard (170) as well as #2 Princeton (110) and #3 MIT (121). Notice that gap? I sure did.


Read Entire Article......

Sunday, August 22, 2010

It's Showtime, Folks!

Syllabus ready? check

On-line homework ready? check

First day activities prepared? check

Lab instructors prepared? looks like it


Campus parking lots empty? not for long!


I love visiting campus on the weekend before classes start. There are always a few freshmen wandering around looking for their classes, probably under the mistaken impression that they will be able to drive up and park right in front of the buildings. Ha! Not unless they get there before 7:30 AM.


Read Entire Article......

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Offices

Inspired by a dream Profgrrrrl had about being forced to swap offices, I remembered that I was talking to my old major professor this past week and he came up with an hysterical, slightly fictional, story:

All of the faculty in a certain new building spend all of their time walking around looking for a better office or any lab space that they might be able to steal. No one dares leave a lab too clean out of fear it might look vacant and get taken from them.

He added that the only thing that distracted these faculty from looking for more lab space was their attempts to get someone else to teach their class next semester so they could do more research.

Their challenge? No one wants to take over their class unless they get a nicer office or some of that precious lab space in trade. Catch 22! As a result, they wander the halls forever like Marley's Ghost, dragging a chain of publications behind them and moaning about offices and teaching loads to anyone who will listen.

When they need a rest, they go to the Dean's office and moan there.


Read Entire Article......

Tuesday, August 10, 2010

Thesis Repulsion Potential

Jorge Cham is brilliant.

Follow the link above to his latest cartoon at PHD Comics. Click to the previous comic to see the setup.

For those of you who don't know this, which might be everyone reading this blog, the potential shown in that cartoon is typical of the attractive force that holds protons and neutrons in the atomic nucleus. The nuclear force is short range and weakly attractive, but there is a very large repulsion at short distances that arises, essentially, from the Pauli exclusion principle acting between the quarks that make up the proton and neutron.

That repulsion sets the size of neutron stars.


Read Entire Article......

Monday, August 9, 2010

Data Storage Media

An important reminder from Unbalanced Reaction about data backup brought the following question to mind:

How many different types of storage media do you have at home? (I don't care if you have the hardware to read them or not.)

Although I suspect I am missing something, here is my list of the 9 (possibly 11) different types of media that are in my house:


  • Internal magnetic disk and external half-terabyte drive (I think it is also magnetic)

  • Flash drives

  • CD ROM

  • DVD

  • Zip disks! (that part of Zoolander is so out of date now)

  • 3.5" floppies

  • [uncertain] 5" floppies (I might have tossed those)

  • [uncertain] 8" floppies (ditto, written under CP/M)

  • Magnetic cassette tapes for an auto-loader backup system

  • 9 track tapes (plural)

  • punched cards

Time to do some more summer house cleaning ....


Read Entire Article......

Friday, August 6, 2010

Mathematics (and Physics) and Calculators

This is the third of three articles concerning calculators and mathematics triggered by a blogspot and IHE blog article by Dean Dad, a community college dean who appears to be writing from another part of the country yet has the same problems we have at our CC. The original article concerned calculator use in Developmental math classes that typically cover fractions and 7th grade algebra, but the comments spanned a range from that topic through mathematics and its applications beyond calculus. My first article merely laid out a common set of definitions, but does include a few assertions about various types of calculators and levels of mathematics that might deserve comment. The second article tried to focus on Developmental math but also included some comments about Algebra. In between these, I posted a shorter article that included a more polemical set of comments about the "modern" Z80-based Graphing calculators. Comments on the second article made me realize I also owe the community a long-deferred article about the math preparation of elementary ed teachers.

My second article limited itself to classes that are remedial in the sense that their goal is to get students to finally learn skills that were supposed to be taught in elementary and middle school as well as the first year or so of high school. College Algebra occupies a fuzzy territory because it is sometimes learned in high school (where it would be Algebra II) but is considered a college-level math class that is sometimes a general education requirement. I included it in my previous article because it is not the only gen-ed math option at our CC and serves many masters. In this article, I will take up the issue of most interest to me: whether students are prepared to use calculators and algebra to do physics, calculus, and (perhaps) engineering problems.

My expectations

As noted earlier, I allow my students to use a Scientific calculator and I expect them to have a decent one and be fairly fluent in its use. I do not allow them to use a Graphing calculator or one that is capable of doing computer algebra. The former is excluded because I do not have time to police all of them for cheat sheets, the latter is excluded because I want a level playing field. They can use MathCAD or Maple or Mathematica when they get into upper division classes where everyone will be using equivalent tools on any given assignment. I expect them to do algebra with pencil and paper in a freshman physics class.

The calculus teachers here have a similar expectation. Many (but not all) give exams where no calculators are allowed on part of the test, but a Graphing calculator (mainly for the numerical integration feature that is on some Scientific calculators as well) is allowed on others. Sometimes they even use a computer algebra program on an exam, but that is rare.

One thing I mentioned in a comment on Dean Dad's blog was the importance of defining outcomes. I forgot to mention that outcomes are best defined so the match the desired inputs for a subsequent class. It is for that reason that our calculus faculty require that students actually know certain derivatives cold, like times tables, and why they were stunned into disbelief when a student transferred here from a school where they used an Algebraic calculator that can do all of the basic derivatives and integrals symbolically. That outcome (being able to take a derivative with a calculator) is mismatched to the requirements of physics and engineering. (True, an engineer taking the "fundamentals" exam has a reference book handy that contains the basic derivatives, but the few minutes you are given to answer each question does not give you enough time to look up every basic result.)

Physics

In general terms, my views on calculators are similar to what Chad Orzel wrote in response to Dean Dad's blog. Real math (meaning math major math classes) have no need at all for calculators unless the topic is numerical analysis, and then you are better off with a programmable computer. Ditto for upper division physics majors classes, although they can have a computational component as well (that is, arithmetic rather than the symbolic mathematics of algebra or calculus). My impression from former students is that engineering expects correct computation as well as algebra, so exams require computation as well as the proper setup of the problem.

I should add that the exam security issues inherent in larger classes, where students are unavoidably sitting within copying range, also requires numerical variations between problems. (Exam fairness has, so far, kept me from putting totally different problems on versions used in the same class.) Most on-line homework systems also do this, although some have symbolic variations as well as numerical ones. This leads to an emphasis on problems with numerical values.

Further, because my students tell me what they do in their first engineering classes, I know computation is only part of it. Setting up the problem algebraically and simplifying before computing is ALSO part of it. For this reason, I require them to state the problem symbolically before plugging in the numbers. However, primarily because of their comfort level, I do not take off if they do the algebra with numbers present rather than keep the symbols until the end. (Having numbers and unknowns makes it easier for most of them to keep track of what is unknown and needs to be isolated or eliminated.) I'll let someone else break them of that habit later on, but I will encourage them to work on it in my class. That said, I do sometimes give exam problems where a symbol like L has to be in the final answer. See below.

Computing

What has surprised me is the degree to which students either cannot compute efficiently or use their calculators inappropriately when solving a problem.

The first problem has only become evident to me recently. I don't think it is a new development; I just happened to see a particularly egregious case last year where the student would evaluate something like A*B*C/D by doing A*B, write down the answer, enter the answer*C, write down that answer, then enter that answer/D. Painful. And slow. And prone to error. I should have suspected this sort of problem because the other version, entering ((A*B)*C)/(D), is a bit of craziness not uncommon in Algebra classes. They don't know order of operations and, even if they do, some have used bad calculators that violate those rules and been burned.

This is, however, a real handicap. They need to use one calculator type and use it enough to understand what it does under different circumstances, but might never have been taught that it is OK (and even necessary) to hit lots of buttons and see what they do under different circumstances. I'm going to mention that this year, going beyond such simple things as whether your calculator does -3^2 correctly or whether it knows automatically that the arcsin of 2 (or the ln of -1) is imaginary.

The second problem is doing algebra with long messy numbers in the equations. This came up in an earlier blog post about algebra, with some nice observations in the comments. This summer I've been thinking about where this comes from, and I am convinced it is because they never use realistic numbers in Algebra classes. Their equations all have numerical coefficients that are small whole numbers, not the 10 digit value for the y component of the velocity, v*sin(theta). There is no penalty for using 3 as a coefficient. There is a penalty for using 34.5619288 as a coefficient. They also seem to have not been exposed much to subscripts, so they are initially quite uncomfortable using Vx as a symbolic replacement for that nasty number.

My preferred solution would be to have pre-calc and trig classes use symbols with subscripts so they get comfortable with that math skill, just as I would like them to work with functions like g(y) or x(t) or even x(y). As we talk more about outcomes at my college, I have to see where those skills fit into the goals of our math curriculum. It might be that these are one-and-done skills (like some skills in physics) because instructors at one level don't know how important it is when you do kinematics in physics or power series in calculus and how much students struggle with those concepts. However, I also know that this is overly optimistic. Instead, I am thinking about ways to work those in from the beginning in my class, perhaps by starting with y(t) motion rather than x(t) motion and using vy and ay even when they aren't really required at that point.

Finally, there is the way I model doing problems in class. Comment number 4 on Chad's article mentioned math exams where you could only use a calculator on part two, something some of our math teachers do, but then came up with a nice insight:

it also could be used to introduce the concept of only taking out your calculator when you reach the stage where you've gotten the problem to its simplest state, and need only put in the numbers.

I've seen students do exactly that while taking an exam, just as I do, but I've never thought about really making a SHOW of pulling out the calculator at that point of the problem. I need to model that step as clearly and explicitly as I model algebraic steps when solving a problem. I also need to find or invent more problems where a symbol is in the final answer, like it would be if you were writing a program where a few values are fed in by the user but others are fixed by material properties or whatever.


Read Entire Article......

65 years since Hiroshima

One of these years I need to plan that vacation trip that includes a stop at Pearl Harbor before heading on to Japan in early August. I need to see where my car was built and visit ground zero of the first A-bomb used in combat as well as the place where it all started for the US in the Pacific. And Kyoto.

One of the odd things about these anniversaries is that, for my students, much more time has elapsed since Vietnam ended than had elapsed between the end of WW II and when I was finishing high school.

Another odd thing is that the film of the bomb going off was either taken or witnessed by someone I once knew, but he never talked about the experience. (In contrast, other people I know who worked on the Manhattan project or other war-related enterprises - such as code breaking - have shared that history and their views of the project.)

One particular irony is that there was an editorial about radiation exposure limits just a few days ago. (Hat tip to Chad at Uncertain Principles.) The dose limits were adjusted based on what was learned from single (acute) dose exposures at Hiroshima, but the editorial argues that we need to look more closely at the evidence from low level (chronic) exposures documented in the 60+ years since those first studies.

PS - I tweaked the posting time to match when (by Japan time) the bomb was dropped.


Read Entire Article......

Thursday, August 5, 2010

Does your campus web site suck too?

I howled when I saw this on xkcd, which I read regularly:


Nailed it!

I visit college web sites while advising future transfer students, and it is rare to find one that makes it easy to find what a student needs, even if they have a "prospective student" link on the front page. And our college web site is as bad as most. So it pleased me a lot to see IHE pick this up in a story Wednesday.

I really like the comment objecting to the "three clicks" problem for key information, and REALLY like the person who is taking this cartoon to every meeting of a CC website revision committee meeting.

But the funniest part was the observation about pictures of "pretty girls studying under trees" on the home page.

Does your college have a photo roll including ethnically diverse but atypically good looking students studying under trees? Ours does. Using computers? (Yep) Interacting in a small group with a distinguished looking professor? (Yep) A link that takes you directly to the academic calendar or the college's majors with a clear list of requirements? (Sort of)

UPDATE:
IHE has a followup story about efforts at web redesign that starts with the student. Interesting followup. I know our college web site has been redesigned to use pull-down menus that have a laundry list of possible links, but we simply do not have a "prospective student" category nor any sense that most of the links off the front are not used.

However, I also have to wonder if "prospective" is too fancy a word for many of our incoming students, the ones that place into developmental reading classes.


Read Entire Article......

Saturday, July 31, 2010

Trucks and Trailers and Vans - Oh My!

The first official sign of Fall!

Today appears to be the first Student Moving Weekend.

The first hint was the sudden appearance of U-Haul trucks over the last few days, some of which might have been people clearing out at the end of July, but students were clearly moving into rental houses around the area today.

Traffic accidents and under age parties won't be far behind.


Read Entire Article......

Thursday, July 29, 2010

Calculators and Basic Math

This is the second of three articles concerning calculators and mathematics triggered by a blog article by Dean Dad, a community college dean who appears to be writing from another part of the country yet has the same problems we have at our CC. I have already commented on the blogspot version of this blog (more than once), which has collected a huge number of comments, but there are also a large number of comments on the IHE version of the same posting. I'll write as if you have at least read Dean Dad's article. The discussion has been quite wide ranging, often not bothering to make a distinction between the various levels of "calculator" available to students or the many levels of math classes they might be used in. (Definitions are given here to provide a common reference.)

In this article, I will take up the specific issue raised in Dean Dad's blog and the one I know the least about as an instructor - calculators and developmental mathematics - but also look at college algebra. I'm mainly interested in putting some of my thoughts on paper and seeing feedback I get from others about their opinions of the problem.

I'll start with a particularly telling comment from Dean Dad:

...part of me wonders if we’re sacrificing too much on the altar of pencil and paper. It’s great to be able to do addition in your head and long division on paper -- yes, I know, I’m old -- but is it worth flunking out huge cohorts of students because their high schools let them use calculators and we don’t?
This isn't about LETTING them use calculators. Part of it is about spending time teaching them how to use a specific brand of calculator rather than how to do algebra. However, as I wrote in my first comment on DD's blog (9:11 AM time stamp about halfway into the 50 or so comments that are there now), I think this is mostly correlation without causation. The real problem lies elsewhere.

I think the problem starts in K-5 and gets compounded by pushing kids along into the next class and lying about the content level of that class. That is, I don't believe for a minute that a student I advised had passed a REAL pre-calc class in HS just a week before I talked to her. DD writes about similar cases:
...students who have passed algebra and even pre-calc in high school frequently crash and burn when they hit our developmental math, because the high schools let them use calculators and we don’t.
I don't buy it, and here is why: Our placement test will put them into Intermediate even if they can't do arithmetic, provided their algebra score is high enough. And you can't work with logarithms and exponentials or trig identities (a given if it is really pre-calc) if you can't solve a simple linear equation written symbolically like I asked the student to do.

You might forget 6 months of math in a week, the newest stuff, but not 3 years of it. And if you do forget that much that fast, you should have failed that pre-calc class. You can't get to much new material if you spend most of the year re-teaching three years of previously-taught material de novo.

K-5 Curriculum:

I don't want to belabor this, but one reason they can't do arithmetic might be that they never learned it. I'm convinced this is the biggest problem we face because it also lies behind the existence of pre-calc classes that are really teaching basic algebra. I'm sure part of it is that teachers who never understood math and hate it with a passion are teaching it by-the-book following a curriculum none of you could possibly imagine anyone would use.

My analogy is to the "look say" approach to reading, where guessing replaced phonetic decoding of words and Johnny (not to mention a cousin with a high IQ who is now an senior engineer at the VP level) couldn't read. Using guessing to construct your own mathematics might work with someone like me (I feel eternal guilt for, AFAICT, being an unwitting subject in a math ed research project that was run before the days of IRB and informed consent where they deduced that this curriculum worked really well), but it is unlikely to work with someone who was not going to get a PhD in physics. Really good algorithms were developed 12 centuries ago and survived for a reason. As is illustrated here, for the Everyday Math curriculum, the most efficient methods are not taught first or (in some cases) are not taught at all in some schools. The starting point for Dean Dad might be to get out into the feeder systems for his CC and find what they are doing in fourth and fifth grade.

If I know anything about learning, it is that students always favor the first method they get taught. (That is one reason you have to really emphasize when conservation of energy or momentum should be used instead of Newton's Laws: they learned F=ma first so it is the first thing they want to try. I'm the same way.) That means it is a really bad idea to start with an inefficient method, but which some people find useful when doing 'mental math', and teach the more efficient one last.

Now think about how to teach synthetic division or multiplication of polynomials to someone who only knows partial quotients division or the lattice method for multiplication. Not pretty. Then consider that they might never have even heard about "invert and multiply". Not pretty at all.

Outcomes:

The answer to Dean Dad's fundamental question, whether students should be allowed to use calculators in an Arithmetic class, starts at the beginning - the first step of course design. What are the desired outcomes for this math course? If the outcome is to be able to do a certain amount of arithmetic with pencil and paper (not in their heads), then the only use of a calculator is to check your own work as you make up your own problem and solve it. Ditto if the purpose is to simplify fractions involving simple whole numbers as preparation for a similar skill with symbols. You need to change the outcomes before changing what you do in the class.

Personally, I'd be happy if they taught them how to do arithmetic on their Basic calculator. Seriously! My biggest complaint when teaching physics isn't that they can't do arithmetic (they can't), it is that they can't calculate worth a damn. Digital natives my ass. I was 22 when I got my first calculator and I am faster than most of them are, and I'm slower than I used to be. (Sure, I've been using one longer than they have been alive, but that only proves they haven't used the thing enough to be competent with it.) I mean, I've watched a student work out a product by multiplying two numbers, writing it down times all of the others, entering it again !!! and multiplying it by the next, etc etc.

I know they use their calculators a lot in our Algebra (meaning College Algebra) classes, but it must all be with simple whole numbers like we used back when there were no calculators. That is the only possible explanation for their struggles with 3 and 4 digit decimal or scientific notation numbers or their mysterious belief in rounding intermediate answers.

Algebra:

There really shouldn't be many numbers in an algebra class, IMHO. Somehow the appearance of Graphing calculators changed the curriculum to emphasize numbers and, curiously, de-emphasize graphing. Since you can't actually read a graph on a TI display screen, let alone interpolate on it using a ruler, they don't appear to know how to make or read an actual graph rather than a cartoon of a graph. This is a nightmare in the physics lab, but also in the classroom when data are supplied in a graphical representation.

I don't believe anyone has tried teaching algebra with a Scientific calculator and graph paper in decades. I doubt if anyone other than the textbook and calculator companies have studied it, and studies like that are notorious for the difficulty in controlling the student mix or the instructor effect. However, stories about students who finally got algebra in a class where only symbols were used - no calculators needed - are common enough to make one wonder how it would work. The studies (see some comments toward the end) seem to lack a smoking gun in favor of the primitive Graphing calculators used today.

There is another side effect. Since they don't know how to use their calculators, particularly concerning order of operations, they use parentheses like they were the only operator known to man. ((3)(2))/((5)). One result is they don't see the key role of the parenthesis to denote "function of". I've seen calculus students who think x(t) means x*t, although this could be partly due to the fact that x is never a function in calculator-based Algebra. I have to wonder out loud if this would improve if they all used HP calculators instead of TI calculators. Also see my next comment below.

Commenting on the comments:

Some Anonymous, writing at 5:56 PM, about 3/4 of the way into the comments, writes:
A kid that is getting good marks in algebra screws up their physics equations. i check with their math teacher, and they don't make those mistakes in math class. So I test them myself, and they can manage algebra just fine when x, y, and z are variables and a, b, c, and d are constants. Anything else and they're lost.
This could be a result of using graphing calculators. The TI-83 will only plot Y(X) unless it is in one of the other modes (where it is similarly limited). Parametric mode, the only place where you can do X(T), does not appear to be used at all until they get to Calc III. This really bugs a chemistry colleague, because they are always plotting the log of this versus the sqrt of that, neither of which is X or Y. Similarly, we start out in physics by plotting x on the Y axis and t on the X axis and it blows their minds. I'm tempted to start by doing only y(t) problems at the start of fall, then moving to x(t).

Mthgeek, aka timfc, writing at 7:45AM of the second day of comments, listed several references. The first of these was
The Arithmetic Gap
Educational Leadership, v61 n5 p55 Feb 2004
Summary: The students using calculators in school classrooms result in lower math scores than students who never use them.
I'd like to know what grade level this was, but it sounds like K-8 from the title. As for the second one that was listed, I don't ever pay attention to something like a meta analysis of 42 other papers that span middle school through calculus. Apples, oranges, confounding variables, design differences, and systematic errors make a tasty goulash but don't help with teaching Basic algebra. One other reference, discussing "computer assisted instruction" would appear to be irrelevant to this discussion. You can use computers as an instructional aid (instant HW feedback, for example) without using a graphing calculator - or any calculator at all.

However, the last reference from Mthgeek is rather interesting. It is a link to an article (Refocusing Introductory College Mathematics Courses) that has a link to a new textbook (Contemporary College Algebra: Data, Functions, Modeling) that implements some of the ideas from the study. That is, the study and the textbook are closely coupled, but I recognize some things in that report that are reflected in what we do in our Intermediate class with a different book. (I'll have to ask around, but we might have made this choice because Intermediate is a pseudo-terminal course for many majors in our curriculum. The situation discussed in the article does not apply as much to our college Algebra course, because it normally leads to business calculus or trig. The statement in that report that biological sciences don't go beyond Algebra is patently false in our curriculum. They have to take Calculus even if they don't ever use it.) That said, I strongly criticize the textbook author for conflating a graph on a Graphing calculator with a graph produced on a computer. There is no comparison in detail or quality.

Some Anonymous, writing at 11:21AM on the first day, said (in part):
1) middle school math is more focused on algebra as early as 7th grade. So students don't have enough mastery of fractions, percents etc
...
3) More students attending college- so the lack of good high school prep is more evident.
4) Content of dev math courses in college are aimed at preparing students for a precalc/calculus track. But those going into sociology or psychology ...

Developmental math at my CC is about preparing students for 9th grade math, not pre-calc. The Intermediate course barely prepares them for real Algebra, and certainly not for the calculus track. (Our failure rate is spectacular at every one of those steps.) Besides. students going into Psychology need a real, college-level statistics class that has college Algebra as a pre-req. Criminal Justice, on the other hand, has no real math requirements and our statistics show that the combination of our Developmental and Intermediate classes does a GREAT job of preparing them to pass the basic financial math class that constitutes their "college level" math requirement while teaching them about compound interest.

The fact that they have not learned arithmetic or fractions by the time they get to 7th grade (which is when we started Basic algebra when I was growing up) is the real problem. Three years should be enough if the curriculum and teachers were any good, but if they aren't or the kids don't learn it in 3 years, our schools track those kids away from Basic algebra for another year, or more. But this does help strengthen my point that the problem is really in the K-5 classroom.

I don't buy the "more students" argument because the fraction going to college has not changed that much in the last few decades.

Finally ...

If you have read this far, thank you. I want to close by saying that the problem really is deeply rooted in our educational system and very frustrating for all involved. The high failure rate in Developmental classes is a major problem that no one is ignoring at our CC.

However, many students fail because they never attend class, or don't attend frequently enough to engage with the instructor. With any instructor, no matter how talented ze might be. I've written about that in an old bit of wishful thinking about new student orientation. Coming straight out of HS, they believe they were taught pre-calculus or Algebra II, so they just don't believe they need to go to class and actually learn math. Older students, out of school for years or decades, know they don't remember anything from school so they take it seriously and often do quite well. An age-based breakdown of performance in Developmental classes might be worth looking at, Dean Dad.

Or Dean Dad might only need to walk by a classroom or three on a regular basis and take a sort of visual attendance. Is the room still full after 4 weeks? Maybe that, rather than calculators, is the real problem.


Read Entire Article......

Interlude - Calculator history

This cartoon from last week really captured my view of "modern" calculators.


Click on the image to see the entire cartoon from XKCD, including the highly relevant punch line.

I was originally going to riff off of this cartoon to discuss "modern technology" in the classroom, but then Dean Dad's article came along. Just for perspective, the current model (TI-83 Plus) shows up priced between $89.99 (on sale at Staples for the new school year) and just under $100 (at Walmart and Amazon). For comparison, the CPI says $110 in 1996 will buy about $150 of normal goods today, but computer prices have been going down even as performance increases. For many decades.

Further, the cartoon is not exaggerating the connection to 1996. Today's TI-83 Plus is still running on a 6 MHz Zilog Z80 microprocessor, an 8-bit cpu that dates to the mid 1970s (as an upgrade to the legendary Intel 8080 chip). The Z80 was used in such memorable machines as the Kaypro II (running CP/M), the TRS-80, and the Sinclair and Timex notebook-sized computers. [The Kaypro, like the Osborne, was a "luggable" computer that would have to be sent in checked baggage today. I still remember using both of those.]

Not exactly MODERN technology, particularly when you consider the limitations of the 96x64 screen compared to, say, a (much smaller) iPhone. This has practical effects in that the calculator has great trouble graphing certain kinds of functions and the interface for "tracing" to a zero is really crude. More importantly, for whatever reason, I see no improvement in algebra skills associated with the month or more of time spent specifically on using this technology. Students do not use the graphs to check their answers, but that is a topic for my other postings on this topic.

Other observations:

The Plus indicates it has 512 kB of flash memory rather than 32 kB of RAM on the original model. The Silver Edition has a 15 MHz cpu and even more memory, but the added speed is one reason why you can clear its memory so much faster than on the Plus. AFAIK, the main difference is that you can clear uploaded programs on the 83 Plus but cannot clear the equivalent programs that are installed OEM on the Silver Edition. The main advantage for students is that you can connect any of these to a computer and download modestly sophisticated applications into Flash memory that are run with the Apps key.

Naive instructors believe that students have to laboriously type in crude crib sheets listing, say, trig identities or chemistry and physics formulas as fake programs. Many do this, but TI provides sophisticated, indexed crib cards - and similar tools are also available from others on the internets. Anyone who "limits" students to a note card of notes but allows a TI-83 without clearing it is laughably naive. Might as well let them bring in a notebook.


Read Entire Article......

Calculators - Background Info

This is the first of three articles concerning calculators and mathematics triggered by a blogspot and IHE blog article by Dean Dad, a community college dean who appears to be writing from another part of the country yet has the same problems we have at our CC. The original article concerned calculator use in "developmental" math classes that typically cover fractions and 7th grade algebra. I have already commented on the blogspot version of this blog (more than once) and the two together have generated more than 80 comments. I added some more in my second article of this series.

I won't actually comment on this topic here. My purpose is solely to set the terms of the debate, as it were, because the wide-ranging discussions of this topic by Dean Dad and others are seldom clear about which of the four or more levels of "calculator" available to students are being discussed and/or which of the three or more levels of math classes (plus physics and chemistry) provides the context for the discussion.

The divisions I make are somewhat arbitrary and perhaps idiosyncratic, so I want to spell them out somewhere without cluttering up a discussion of the teaching and learning issues as I see them. That way I can link here for future discussions of this topic and not have to repeat myself.

Although I think three levels of "calculator" suffice for most classroom use, and hence for later discussion, I think I need to list at least five to make the definitions as sharp as possible.

  • Basic - Here I have in mind a wide range of very cheap calculators that can do arithmetic, including parentheses and scientific notation, but cannot deal with trig functions.

  • SCIENTIFIC - These calculators can evaluate all of the basic functions (trig, hyperbolic, log, exponential, power) but cannot store text or programs. Some can work with complex numbers and/or hexadecimal numbers. At the high end, some can numerically evaluate definite integrals or derivatives or solve simple equations, but they cannot show any intermediate algebraic steps or work purely with symbols.

  • GRAPHING - Here I have in mind several calculators that are similar in capability to the TI-83Plus. They can do all of the calculations of a top end "Scientific" calculator, but can also make graphs and store programs (including large amounts of text that can serve as a sophisticated crib sheet). They can store text, but cannot work with symbols. Functions are limited to y(x) except in the rarely-used parametric or polar modes.

  • ALGEBRAIC - These calculators can solve equations written symbolically and can, in some cases, even show step-by-step the algebra or calculus used in the solution. They are typically somewhat limited in how much calculus they can do symbolically, but they make it unnecessary to learn any of the derivatives typically encountered in calculus.

  • Computer Algebra - Here I have in mind small computers that can run computer algebra programs like Maple, Mathematica, MathCAD, etc. Now you might say "a laptop is not a calculator", but there is actually a rather modest size difference between a notebook-sized laptop and the top end TI "calculator" that comes with a full keyboard and a wide screen. Besides, these are widely used in classes at the Junior level and above so they help frame the discussion.

The three in the middle, in all caps, are the ones I will refer to most often within the context of lower division classes taught at a community college.

For the record, I allow Scientific calculators in my introductory physics classes but do not allow formula sheets or cell phones or Graphing calculators to be used on exams. I encourage students to get one of the high-end Scientific calculators that can be used throughout their engineering career, including on licensing exams, so they become fluent in its use.

The four levels of mathematics classes are defined as follows:
  • Developmental - The content here ranges from arithmetic and fractions (what I characterize as 4th and 5th grade math) to basic algebra (the first class where "x" is used, taught in 7th grade when I was in school). These do not carry college credit. A well-calibrated placement test determines where a student starts, and some have an exit exam to verify competency at a certain level.

  • Intermediate - The content here is algebra through what I knew as the 9th grade level (the quadratic formula, for example, but no logarithms). This might earn college credit at a community college, but not at a university. It is not considered to be at the college level. A well-calibrated placement test is used to place students in or through this level of math.

  • College Algebra and Trig - I group all of the pre-calculus "college level" courses here but exclude other "college level" classes that exist mainly to ensure that liberal arts majors can graduate even if they can't do college algebra. (Those other classes usually cover enough about exponential behavior to understand compound interest on credit cards and enough probability so you should know better than to play the lottery, both very valuable life skills!) At our college, College Algebra serves many masters so skills not needed for the pre-business curriculum are put in an "advanced" college algebra class (pre-calc) and a trig class. (I know that some colleges, like my high school and undergrad university, combine these into a single course but I will use our curriculum as my reference point.) A different, also well calibrated, test is used to place students above this level although most students take the class.

  • Calculus - Although my students will usually take everything through differential equations and linear algebra, I'm mainly thinking about first semester calculus because that is where the bulk of students fail.

The distinction between Developmental and Intermediate might seem unnecessary to some readers, because both levels are usually non-credit classes at a university. Indeed, some universities define college algebra as a remedial course. I make the distinction because our math department teaches classes at the Intermediate level and above, while the Developmental classes are taught by a separate department that specializes in teaching those skills. I know that smaller colleges do not make this distinction, but we are not a small college. (We have more t-t faculty in our Developmental math department than a private school like Union College has in its regular Math department.)

If I just say "Algebra", I mean College Algebra. I will say "Basic Algebra" or "Arithmetic" when I am talking about Developmental skills classes.

For the record, our Developmental classes use a Basic calculator for some things but some exams must be taken without any calculator. (The placement test and exit exam do not allow use of a calculator.) I believe they allow the use of any calculator up through a Graphing calculator when they allow a Basic one, but that might depend on the instructor. Our Intermediate classes all use calculators. Our Algebra classes require a specific Graphing calculator that is also required for statistics. Our calculus classes are a bit less picky about which Graphing calculator students can use, but ban Algebraic calculators and computers except in some special situations.


Read Entire Article......

Friday, July 16, 2010

A big day in history

Today, June 16, is:

  • the 65th anniversary of the first test of an "atomic" bomb outside Alamogordo, NM;

  • the 41st anniversary of the launch of Apollo 11, the first mission to land men on an extraterrestrial body, the Moon.

It is also the 37th anniversary of Butterfield's testimony that President Nixon had been taping conversations inside the oval office, tapes that eventually showed he was guilty of obstruction of justice and other major felonies, but I want to talk about technology today.

So, in the context of "if we can put men on the Moon, why can't we stop the leak at the bottom of the Gulf of Mexico", what is the relative difficulty of these three tasks?

Based solely on the time required to complete the project, the Moon mission was by far the most difficult and complex. The project started more than eight years earlier, before we had even put a man in orbit. Although the Saturn I was already on the drawing boards as an orbital launch vehicle, the Saturn V project started in early 1962. After about 4 years of research and development, there were two unmanned test flights (both showing problems that had to be fixed) before the first manned test flights. Even though we rather boldly used the first manned test flight to orbit the Moon, almost two years elapsed between the first unmanned test and the Moon landing mission. Given that this was a very high priority project that went as fast as possible (too fast, at times, resulting in three astronaut deaths) with essentially unlimited resources in the early years, it is almost nonsensical to compare design and construction of the "capping stack" to a Moon mission.

Next would be the development of the plutonium bomb first tested on this date in 1945. Plutonium was first isolated in 1941, so it only took four years to determine that one isotope, Pu-239, could be used as a nuclear explosive (it was already known that U-235 could be used that way) and figure out how to produce kg quantities of it and turn it into a weapon. Like the Moon mission, this was a "money is no object" project on the same scale as radar and a pressurized bomber that could fly at high altitude and carry a payload big enough to drop an atomic bomb. So, on the basis of time alone, this was easily half as difficult as going to the moon even if you include the U-235 weapon and the need for both radar and that bomber if the project was going to succeed.

Of the two bomb projects going on at the same time, the Pu-239 weapon was by far more complicated technically. The only challenge with U-235 was producing the purified isotope. (That remains the reason it poses the greatest threat for the spread of nuclear weapons, but that is a topic for another day. Our confidence in the U-235 weapon was so high that it was never tested before being used on Hiroshima.) With Pu-239, you had to produce the isotope essentially one atom at a time in a reactor and then separate it chemically from a huge quantity of preposterously radioactive material. Even then, you have to figure out how to assemble it into a weapon that will explode. That was enough of a challenge that it required a test before being used in combat a few weeks later. Again, based on time alone, four years does not compare to a few months of work to develop the capping stack (and the tools to cut off the pipe and install it) as well as the temporary fixes that were used until it was ready.

It is a good thing that fixing the mistakes made by BP was not nearly as complicated as rocket science or weapons. Those took years, this took months.

As I said yesterday, I don't think most people realize how long it takes to design and build something, even something as "simple" as a highway. You don't notice it until construction begins, but the work was going on for years before that.


Read Entire Article......

Thursday, July 15, 2010

Failure of the New Media

When looking for the official BP info about the status of the well in the gulf, I found the following comment on the Huffington Post's Social News prominently in the news stack on Google:

FREEDOM BELL

“Me either. When did Wells of BP issue email and comments during the past attempts. When did Obama ever go on TV during a past attempt?”
(This was a comment on a Huffington Post article reporting the great news that the well had been "shut in".)

Since Wells of BP issues a comment twice a day, and this one came during his regularly scheduled briefing, the answer is he always does this. How do I know? The link I was looking for when I Googled "BP" was their Gulf of Mexico response page. The schedule and transcripts of those briefings is the top link on that page, and shows a 2:30 CDT (3:30 EDT) briefing, the second of the day.

And anyone with a modicum of knowledge of politics knows that the President will hold a press conference or give a speech whenever he feels like it, usually several times a day.

Conclusion: This contributor to the New Media has no critical thinking skills and/or no ability to use the web to answer this question, or only has an interest in using rhetorical questions to malign the motives of the engineers trying to solve this problem and the politicians making sure they do what the law requires them (not the government) to do.

Much the same can be said of the following comment
Equinator

85 days, 16 hours. Why was this not done the first day? All that planning to watch out for the walruses must not have helped much.

Correct, but even if the planning had said they would try this, they would still have had to build the device after being sure it was engineered to work in this specific situation. I don't know what they teach the great unwashed masses in school, but nothing of any complexity can be done in a day. (It takes years to take a new car model from design to showroom floor. I saw a version of the Ford Fusion in 1999.)

The reality is that this is a magnificent accomplishment. No other failure of this type (there have been others) was stopped prior to the drilling of a relief well, let alone one at this depth.

Now, even if the casing below lacks integrity and they have to keep the valve open (which is what they have expected all along), they can connect this to surface ships and keep any more oil from going into the Gulf. Lets hope the pressure and seismic tests show no oil leaking down in the drill hole itself. That would be even better news.


Read Entire Article......

Thursday, July 8, 2010

OMG - It's July!

I had planned to post this a week ago (obviously), so by now Dr. Crazy has beaten me to the punch. Yes, it is that time of year, the time when you realize that next month is August! The month when classes begin. Lest we forget, the month when meetings begin! The month when there will be a number of things on the table (figuratively and literally) that you know you could have done, oh, in July. Or June.

As an inveterate procrastinator, I have used false deadlines for ages. In this case, I am now pretending we are approaching mid August rather than mid July. Those things that need to be printed for the first few labs, the ones that don't even need to have a date changed? They are going to get done this month. After all, my classes are all full (and one is overflowing) so I know what the number count is likely to be and any leftovers can be used next semester.

Syllabus for fall? Almost done, apart from one tweak and final check of the calendar and exam schedule. Syllabus for the spring? Next on my list. (Winter break is always too short.) Busy work I know I will need to do during the semester? I actually got the template updated so I only have to work on the worst part of it during the next month along with one task I have simply avoided doing for, oh, about two years.

And I plan to clean my office. Next week.


Read Entire Article......